SUN Yan,LI Minmin,HAN Bin,et al.Identification and Comprehensive Evaluation on RootCold Resistance of Six Grape Varieties[J].Northern Horticulture,2021,(17):30-37.[doi:10.11937/bfyy.20210488]
六个葡萄品种根系抗寒性鉴定及综合评价
- Title:
- Identification and Comprehensive Evaluation on RootCold Resistance of Six Grape Varieties
- Keywords:
- grape; root; cold resistance indexes; comprehensive evaluation
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 以“左山一”“5C”“5BB”“SO4”“红地球”和“巨峰”6个葡萄品种一年生根系为试材，测定经人工低温胁迫处理后的相对电导率、总含水量、自由水含量、根系硬度及做功量，应用电导法配合Logistic方程计算供试品种的低温半致死温度，利用聚类分析法、隶属函数法及相关分析综合评价各品种的抗寒性。探究适宜评价葡萄品种抗寒性的方法，以期为葡萄抗寒性评价方法体系的建立及抗寒育种工作提供参考依据。结果表明：各品种根系相对电导率均随着温度的降低而升高；“左山一”根系总含水量、自由水含量及自束比（自由水含量/束缚水含量）均显著低于其它品种，横切硬度、横切总功和纵切总功均显著高于其它品种；“红地球”总含水量、自由水含量及自束比均显著高于其它品种，横切硬度、横切总功、纵切硬度和纵切总功均最小，且此4项指标与其它品种间均达差异显著水平。根据聚类分析结果，6个葡萄品种抗寒性强弱归为3类,“左山一”抗寒性最强;“5BB”“SO4”和“5C”抗寒性居中;“红地球”和“巨峰”抗寒性较弱。由隶属函数值得出各葡萄品种抗寒性强弱顺序为“左山一”＞“SO4”＞“5BB”＞“5C”＞“巨峰”＞“红地球”。相关性分析可得，根系半致死温度与总含水量、自由水含量及自束比间均呈极显著正相关，与横切总功间呈极显著负相关，与纵切硬度和纵切总功间均呈显著负相关。研究表明，根系总含水量、自由水含量、自束比、横切硬度、横切总功、纵切硬度和纵切总功可以作为评价葡萄抗寒性的有效指标，运用聚类分析法结合隶属函数法综合评价葡萄抗寒性更加科学、准确。
- Abstract:
- Roots of annual cutting seedlings of 6 grape varieties,included ‘Zuoshan1’‘5C’‘5BB’‘SO4’‘Red Globe’ and ‘Kyoho’ were selected as experimental materials.The relative conductivity (REC),total water content,free water content,the hardness and total work of roots were measured.And then semi-lethal temperature (LT50) was obtained from the Logistic equation.The data were processed using membership function value method,system cluster and correlation analysis to comprehensively evaluate cold resistance of every variety to explore more suitable evaluation methods of cold resistance of grape.In order to provide reference for the establishment of evaluation method system on cold resistance and cold-resistant breeding work in grape.The results showed that the REC of 6 grape varieties gradually increased with decreasing temperature.Total water content,free water content and the ratio of free water content to bound water content (F/B) in ‘Zuoshan1’ were significantly lower than those in other grape varieties.The cross cutting hardness,cross cutting total work and longitudinal cutting total work were all significantly higher in ‘Zuoshan1’ than those in other grape varieties,respectively.‘Red Globe’ had the maximum content in total water content,free water content and F/B,in which there were significant differences between ‘Red Globe’ and other grape varieties (P<0.05),respectively.The cross cutting hardness,cross cutting total work,longitudinal cutting hardness and longitudinal cutting total work were all the least in ‘Red Globe’,and showed significant differences between ‘Red Globe’ and other varieties,respectively.According to cluster analysis result,6 grape varieties could be divided into 3 groups,‘Zuoshan1’ was of high cold resistance,‘5C’‘5BB’ and ‘SO4’ were of moderate cold resistance,‘Kyoho’ and ‘Red Globe’ were of low cold resistance.The order of the cold resistance according to the average membership function value was ‘Zuoshan1’>‘SO4’>‘5BB’>‘5C’>‘Kyoho’>‘Red Globe’.Correlation analysis showed that LT50 had aextremely significantly positive correlation with total water content,free water content and F/B and a aextremely significantly negative correlation with cross cutting total work.LT50 was negatively related to longitudinal cutting hardness and longitudinal cutting total work.It was concluded that total water content,free water content,F/B,cross cutting hardness,cross cutting total work,longitudinal cutting hardness and longitudinal cutting total work could be evaluation indexes of grape cold resistance.It was more scientific and accurate to combine system cluster and membership function value method on effectively evaluating cold resistance of grape.
参考文献/References:
[1]高登涛，白茹，鲁晓燕，等.引入石河子地区的5个葡萄砧木抗寒性比较[J].果树学报，2015，32(2)：232-237.[2]范宗民，孙军利，赵宝龙，等.不同砧木‘赤霞珠’葡萄枝条抗寒性比较[J].果树学报，2020，37（2）：215-225.[3]BEHESHTI ROOY S S,HOSSEINI SALEKDEH G,GHABOOLI M,et al.Cold-induced physiological and biochemical responses of three grapevine cultivars differing in cold tolerance[J].Acta Physiologiae Plantarum,2017,39(12):264.[4]杨豫，张晓煜，陈仁伟，等.不同品种酿酒葡萄根系抗寒性鉴定[J].中国生态农业学报(中英文)，2020，28(4)：558-565.[5]任静，郝燕，白耀栋，等.河西走廊‘贵人香’7个葡萄砧穗组合抗寒性的综合评价[J].甘肃农业大学学报，2019，54(4)：60-68.[6]王海鸥，高展，艾克拜尔·毛拉，等.自然越冬条件下17个葡萄砧木品种几个生理指标变化分析[J].经济林研究，2019，37(4)：120-128.[7]GAO Z,ZHAI H,DU Y P.Measurement of grape root firmness and its application to the evaluation of cold hardiness[J].Australian Journal of Grape and Wine Research,2018,24(4):406.[8]鲁金星，姜寒玉，李唯.低温胁迫对砧木及酿酒葡萄枝条抗寒性的影响[J].果树学报，2012，29(6)：1040-1046.[9]王文举，张亚红，牛锦凤，等.电导法测定鲜食葡萄的抗寒性[J].果树学报，2007，24(1)：34-37.[10]何伟，艾军，范书田，等.葡萄品种及砧木抗寒性评价方法研究[J].果树学报，2015，32(6)：1135-1142.[11]高俊凤.植物生理学实验指导[M].北京：高等教育出版社，2012.[12]张剑侠，吴行昶，杨亚州，等.引进美国制汁葡萄品种抗寒性的综合评价[J].北方园艺，2011(24)：1-5.[13]苏李维，李胜，马绍英，等.葡萄抗寒性综合评价方法的建立[J].草业学报，2015，24(3)：70-79.[14]李清亚，路斌，赵佳伟，等.不同豆梨品种对低温胁迫的生理响应及抗寒性评价[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版)，2020，48(1)：86-94，110.[15]陈佰鸿，张彪，毛娟，等.葡萄枝条水分含量变化与抗寒性关系[J].植物生理学报，2014，50(4)：535-541.[16]LI P H,SAKAI A.Plant cold hardiness and freezing stress[M].Pittsburgh:Academic Press,1978.[17]何伟，艾军，杨义明，等.山葡萄种质资源枝条的低温半致死温度研究[J].北方园艺，2014(21)：19-22.[18]陈洁，金晓玲，宁阳，等.3种含笑属植物抗寒生理指标的筛选及评价[J].河南农业科学，2016，45(2)：113-118.[19]SU L,DAI Z,LI S,et al.A novel system for evaluating drought-cold tolerance of grapevines using chlorophyll fluorescence[J].BMC Plant Biology,2015,15(1):82.[20]白茹，高登涛，刘怀锋，等.引入石河子地区的葡萄砧木抗寒性研究[J].新疆农业科学，2015，52(2)：210-216.[21]周香云，李爽，李连国，等.低温胁迫对8种葡萄砧木根系细胞膜透性影响的研究[J].内蒙古农业大学学报(自然科学版)，2012，33(4)：51-53.[22]房用，李秀芬，慕宗昭，等.茶树抗寒性研究进展[J].经济林研究，2004,22(2)：69-72.[23]相昆，张美勇，徐颖，等.不同核桃品种耐寒特性综合评价[J].应用生态学报，2011，22(9)：2325-2330.[24]龚月桦，周永学，樊军锋，等.美国黄松、班克松和油松的抗寒性比较[J].应用生态学报,2006，17(8)：1389-1392.[25]杨玉珍，陈刚，彭方仁，等.低温胁迫下不同种源香椿含水量和渗透调节物质含量差异及其与抗寒性的相关性[J].植物资源与环境学报，2014(4)：47-54.[26]TURMANINA V.On the strength of tree roots[J].Bull Moscow Soc Nat Biol Sect,1965,70:36-45.[27]李谦，周本智，安艳飞，等.绿竹根系分布及生物力学性质[J].应用生态学报，2014，25(5)：1319-1326.[28]赵绍宇，李宜达，吴君怡，等.油松和刺槐林木单根含水量对抗拉强度的影响分析[J].南昌工程学院学报，2017，36(4):48-53.[29]袁军伟，郭紫娟，马爱红，等.葡萄砧木抗寒性的鉴定与综合评价[J].中国农学通报，2013，29(4)：99-103.[30]付晓伟，张倩，刘崇怀，等.评价葡萄根系抗寒性指标的确定[J].果树学报，2014，31(1)：52-59.[31]郑凯翔，王旺田，刘文瑜，等.外源硅调控葡萄生理特性对低温胁迫的响应[J].分子植物育种，2020，18(3)：1013-1019.[32]JING L,WANG Y Q,HAN X P,et al.Evaluation of cold hardiness of seven loquat accessions[J].Acta Hort,2015,1092(28):191-198.[33]李桂荣，程珊珊，张少伟，等.葡萄抗寒相关生理生化指标灰色关联分析[J].东北林业大学学报，2018，46(10)：40-47，53.
相似文献/References:
[1]单守明,平吉成,刘晶,等.6-BA对染卷叶病毒葡萄光合作用和果实品质的影响[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):5.
[2]梁浩.枣庄地区气候因子对葡萄生产模式选择的影响[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):55.
[3]张广和,于晓丽,栾炳辉,等.倍创与杀菌剂混用对葡萄果实病害的防效评价[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):127.
[4]李海峰,王瑞华,韩琛,等.新疆葡萄平衡施肥技术发展现状及展望[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):185.
[5]史洪琴,蒋丽光.中短剪葡萄结实特性比较[J].北方园艺,2014,38(12):34.
SHI Hong-qin,JIANG Li-guang.Comparison of Grape Fruit Characteristics After Moderate and Short Pruning[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(17):34.
[6]张剑侠,吴行昶,杨亚州.葡萄种间杂种的抗寒性评价[J].北方园艺,2014,38(13):1.
ZHANG Jian-xia,WU Xing-chang,YANG Ya-zhou.Cold-resistance Evaluation in Grape Interspecific Hybrids[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(17):1.
[7]商佳胤,田淑芬,集 贤,等.果袋颜色对设施葡萄果实品质的影响[J].北方园艺,2014,38(11):42.
SHANG Jia-yin,TIAN Shu-fen,JI Xian,et al.Effect of Fruit Bag Color on Grape Quality in Facility Condition[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(17):42.
[8]王文平.肃州区非耕地日光温室葡萄反季节高效节水栽培技术[J].北方园艺,2014,38(10):43.
[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(17):43.
[9]郑强卿,陈奇凌,李 铭,等.滴灌条件下骏枣根系分布特征及根际土壤水分变化研究[J].北方园艺,2013,37(22):177.
ZHENG Qiang-qing,CHEN Qi-ling,LI Ming,et al.Study on Root Distribution Characteristics and Changes of Rhizosphere Soil Moisture Under Drip Irrigation of Junzao[J].Northern Horticulture,2013,37(17):177.
[10]周 恒,饶 鹏,田如英,等.不同栽培方式下五个葡萄品种在贵州铜仁地区的生产表现[J].北方园艺,2014,38(14):22.
ZHOU Heng,RAO Peng,TIAN Ru-ying,et al.Five Grape Varieties Under Different Cultivations in the Production Performance in Guizhou Tongren Area[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(17):22.
[11]冀鹏飞,薛斌,刘志华,等.干旱胁迫下葡萄根系的生理生化变化与抗旱性的关系[J].北方园艺,2012,36(04):17.
JI Peng-fei,XUE Bin,LIU Zhi-hua,et al.Relationship between Changes of Physiological-biochemical Characteristic of Grape Roots under Drought-stress and Drought-resistant[J].Northern Horticulture,2012,36(17):17.
[12]王金印,郝喜龙,刘志华.葡萄叶片和根系解剖结构与抗旱性关系[J].北方园艺,2017,41(12):43.[doi:10.11937/bfyy.201712010]
WANG Jinyin,HAO Xilong,LIU Zhihua.Relationship Between Anatomical Structure of Grape Leaf and Root and Drought Resistance[J].Northern Horticulture,2017,41(17):43.[doi:10.11937/bfyy.201712010]
备注/Memo
第一作者简介：孙艳（1987-），女，硕士，助理研究员，现主要从事葡萄育种等研究工作。E-mail：sycoolhi@163.com.责任作者：郭紫娟（1964-），女，本科，研究员，现主要从事葡萄育种等研究工作。E-mail:guozijuan64@126.com.基金项目：国家现代农业产业技术体系建设专项资金资助项目（CARS-29-yc-8）；河北省重点研发计划资助项目（20326813D）；河北省农业科技创新工程资助项目(F19R01)。收稿日期：2021-01-28