GAO Zixing,MA Jinfang,HU Xiaohui.Comparison of Yield and Quality of Fruit Tomato Cultivars in Solar Greenhouse in High and Cold Area[J].Northern Horticulture,2019,43(15):61-68.[doi:10.11937/bfyy.20190176]
高寒地区日光温室不同番茄品种产量和品质的比较
- Title:
- Comparison of Yield and Quality of Fruit Tomato Cultivars in Solar Greenhouse in High and Cold Area
- Keywords:
- Qinghai Ledu district; tomato; introduction experiment; yield; quality; hierarchical analysis
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 以18个大果型番茄品种为试材，春季在青海乐都区日光温室栽培，通过测定各番茄品种产量和品质，并利用层次分析方法评价各番茄品种口感、品质（可溶性固形物、有机酸及糖酸比）和营养品质（维生素C、可溶性蛋白质及还原糖）的综合表现。结果表明：在青海乐都区日光温室栽培条件下，“德赛圣帝”番茄产量最高，“神箭爱粉一号”最低；可溶性固形物含量最高的是“黑士”，最低的是“德赛0216”；有机酸含量最高的是“黑士”和“改良超级粉娜”，“世纪粉冠王”和“德赛0216”最低；维生素C含量最高的是“世纪粉冠王”，最低的是“抗TY”；可溶性蛋白质含量最高的是“黑士”，最低的是“奥特福农”；还原糖含量最高的是“黑士”，“德赛硬粉”最低。利用层次分析方法评价各番茄品种口感、品质（可溶性固形物、有机酸及糖酸比）和营养品质（维生素C、可溶性蛋白质及还原糖）的综合表现，品质综合评价分析结果为“德赛圣帝”>“德赛裕宝”>“德赛超冠”>“德赛硬粉”>“德赛0801”>“德赛0216”>“金帝”>“改良超级粉娜”>“德赛明珠”>“奥特福农”>“精选世纪粉冠王”>“抗TY”>“黑士”>“世纪粉冠王二号”>“奥粉一号”>“粉果硬石头”>“世纪粉冠王”>“神箭爱粉一号”；品质与产量综合得分分析结果为“德赛圣地”>“德赛裕宝”>“德赛超冠”>“德赛硬粉”>“德赛0801”>“德赛0216”>“金帝”>“改良超级粉娜”>“德赛明珠”>“奥特福农”>“精选世纪粉冠王”>“抗TY”>“黑士”>“世纪粉冠王二号”>“奥粉一号”>“粉果硬石头”>“世纪粉冠王”>“神箭爱粉一号”。“德赛圣地”和“德赛裕宝”产量和品质综合评分高，适宜在青海省乐都区等高寒地区日光温室推广种植。
- Abstract:
- Eighteen large fruit tomato cultivars were used as materials,and cultivated in Qinghai Ledu district′s greenhouse in spring.The yield and quality of each tomato variety were measured,and the comprehensive performance of the tomato varieties (including soluble solids,organic acids and sugar-acid ratio) and nutritional quality (vitamin C,soluble protein and reducing sugar) were evaluated by hierarchical analysis method.In solar greenhouse cultivation in Qinghai Ledu district,in eighteen large fruit tomato varieties,the highest yield of tomato cultivars was ‘Desaishengdi’,the lowest was ‘Shenjian′aifenyihao’; ‘Heishi’ had the highest content of soluble solids,the lowest was ‘Desai0216’; ‘Heishi’ and ‘Gailiangchaojifenna’ had the highest content of organic acids,the lowest were ‘Jingxuanshijifenwang’ and ‘Desai0216’; ‘Shijifenguanwang’ had the highest content of vitamin C,the lowest was ‘KangTY’; ‘Heishi’ had the highest content of soluble protein,the lowest was ‘Aotefunong’; ‘Heishi’ had the highest content of reducing sugar,the lowest was ‘Desaiyingfen’.Using the hierarchical analysis method to evaluate the comprehensive performance of tomato varieties,the analysis result of comprehensive quality evaluation was ‘Desaishengdi’>‘Desaiyubao’>‘Desaichaoguan’>‘Desaiyingfen’>‘Desai0801’>‘Desai0216’>‘Jindi’>‘Gailiangchaojifenna’>‘Desaimingzhu’>‘Aotefunong’>‘Jingxuanshijifenwang’>‘KangTY’>‘Heishi’>‘Shijifenguanwangerhao’>‘Aofenyihao’>‘FenGuoyingshitou’>‘Shijifenguanwang’>‘Shenjian′aifenyihao’.The comprehensive performance of the tomato varieties (including soluble solids,organic acids and sugar-acid ratio) and nutritional quality (vitamin C,soluble protein and reducing sugar) were evaluated by hierarchical analysis method.Result of quality and output was ‘Desaishengdi’>‘Desaiyubao’>‘Desaichaoguan’>‘Desaiyingfen’>‘Desai0801’>‘Desai0216’>‘Jindi’>‘Gailiangchaojifenna’>‘Desaimingzhu’>‘Aotefunong’>‘Jingxuanshijifenwang’>‘KangTY’>‘Heishi’>‘Shijifenguanwangerhao’>‘Aofenyihao’>‘Fenguoyingshitou’>‘Shijifenguanwang’>‘Shenjian′aifenyihao’.‘Desaishengdi’ and ‘Desaiyubao’ had high yield and quality,those were suitable to popularize planting in the high cold area for example Qinghai Ledu district.
参考文献/References:
[1]张晓东,刘志刚,张勇.设施番茄品种比较试验[J].中国瓜菜,2017,30(6):31-34.[2]程智慧.园艺概论[M].北京:科学出版社,2009.[3]程智慧.蔬菜栽培学各论[M].北京:科学出版社,2010. [4]刘德才.浅谈乐都区春小麦高产栽培技术[J].农业开发与装备,2017(3):157.[5]高君凤.植物生理学实验指导[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2006.[6]马庆华,李永红,梁丽松,等.冬枣优良单株果实品质的因子分析与综合评价[J].中国农业科学,2010,43(12):2491-2499.[7]张晓玮,龚雪梅,李琳,等.基于层次分析法的皖北地区引种的彩叶植物综合评价[J].浙江大学学报(农业与生命科学版),2018,44(5):580-587.[8]陈鹏羽,朱陇强,王紫薇,等.黄土高原区苹果种植适宜性评价：以陕西省永寿县为例[J].陕西农业科学,2019,65(2):94-98.[9]陈惠明,刘晓红.国内外番茄育种现状和发展趋势[J].湖南农业科学,1996(5):25-27.[10]刘梦龙,赵伟,蒋丽媛,等.关中东部早春茬番茄优良品种筛选[J].西北农业学报,2018,27(3):402-410.[11]刘庞源,张宝海,何伟明.传统优良番茄品种与新番茄品种品质比较[J].中国蔬菜,2009,1(10):37-40.[12]张洋,梁燕.日光温室樱桃番茄品种比较试验[J].长江蔬菜,2017(12):41-44.[13]陈宗玲,钟连全,徐全明,等.16个草莓新品种在北京昌平生长结果性状比较[J].中国果树,2018(2):23-28，32.[14]黄文,郭竞,李自娟,等.定植密度和留果穗数对春大棚番茄生长及产量和品质的影响[J].北方园艺,2018(22):79-82.[15]MAHAJAN G,SINGHK G.Response of greenhouse tomato to irrigation and fertigation[J].Agricultural Water Management,2006,84(1-2):202-206.[16]KUSCU H,TURHAN A,OZMEN N,et al.Optimizing levels of water and nitrogen applied through drip irrigation for yield,quality,and water productivity of processing tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)[J].Horticulture Environment & Biotechnology,2014,55(2):103-114.[17]ZOTARELLI L,DUKESA M D,SCHOLBERG J M S,et al.Tomato nitrogen accumulation and fertilizer use efficiency on a sandy soil,as affected by nitrogen rate and irrigation scheduling[J].Agricultural Water Management,2009,96(8):1247-1258.[18]程远,万红建,刘超超,等.十六个樱桃番茄品种果实风味品质相关指标比较分析[J].浙江农业学报,2018(11):1859-1869.[19]秦立金,李嘉薇,李慧敏,等.不同樱桃番茄新品种生长及品质特性比较研究[J].赤峰学院学报(自然科学版),2018,34(11):10-12.[20]王孝宣,李树德,东惠茹,等.番茄品种耐寒性与ABA和可溶性糖含量的关系[J].园艺学报,1998(1):56-60.[21]黄文,李自娟,应芳卿,等.7个早熟抗TY番茄新品种比较试验[J].长江蔬菜,2017(16):48-50.[22]郭伟民,田如霞,王静.山西晋中地区秋冬茬设施番茄品种比较试验[J].种子,2018,37(10):128-129,131.[23]吴久赟,刘翔宇,雷静,等.吐鲁番地区11个葡萄品种的设施栽培特性分析[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版),2018,46(3):134-141.[24]董在成,张艳玲,冯定超,等.天津地区日光温室番茄品种比较试验[J].天津农业科学,2017,23(12):80-84.[25]刘中良,郑建利,焦娟,等.鲁中地区日光温室番茄品种比较试验[J].北方园艺,2017(20):85-88.[26]刘洋,齐艳花,杨恩庶,等.日光温室越冬番茄品种比较试验[J].蔬菜,2017(1):14-18.[27]马中福.民勤县日光温室番茄品种比较试验[J].中国农业信息,2016(23):143.[28]张丽茁.早春棚室早熟高产番茄及黄瓜品种筛选[D].哈尔滨:东北农业大学,2013.
相似文献/References:
[1]吴晓燕,张丽荣,马建华,等.一种新型微生物制剂对设施番茄土壤微生物数量的影响[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):42.
[2]刘配军,李景富,许向阳,等.番茄hp1和dg基因高效检测体系的建立[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):99.
[3]王晓娥,李建国,赵姝荣,等.咸阳市设施番茄根结线虫病的发生与防治[J].北方园艺,2013,37(04):133.
[4]谷婧玥,李景富,许向阳,等.番茄不同果穗间品质性状差异性研究[J].北方园艺,2014,38(12):26.
GU Jing-yue,LI Jing-fu,XU Xiang-yang,et al.Study on Tomato’s Quality and Traits at Different Tassel[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):26.
[5]吕 涛,于 杰,赵 勇.日光温室越冬栽培番茄适宜品种筛选试验[J].北方园艺,2014,38(12):40.
LV Tao,YU Jie,ZHAO Yong.Selection of Overwintering Tomato Varieties Suitable for Solar Greenhouse in Heilongjiang[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):40.
[6]李美芹,裴华丽,乔 宁,等.TYLCV外壳蛋白基因植物表达载体构建及转化番茄的研究[J].北方园艺,2014,38(12):84.
LI Mei-qin,PEI Hua-li,QIAO Ning,et al.Study on the Construction of Plant Expression Vector of TYLCV-CP Gene and Its Transferring Into Tomato[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):84.
[7]李文枫,李景富,许向阳.不同hp基因类型番茄中番茄红素与主要品质性状的差异及相关分析[J].北方园艺,2014,38(13):97.
LI Wen-feng,LI Jing-fu,XU Xiang-yang.Correlation and Difference Analysis Between Lycopene Content and Main Quality Characters of Tomato with Different hp Gene Types[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):97.
[8]张 浩,李福云,徐志然,等.不同套作模式对温室连作番茄生长产量及土壤微生物与酶活性的影响[J].北方园艺,2014,38(13):46.
ZHANG Hao,LI Fu-yun,XU Zhi-ran,et al.Effects of Different Relay Intercropping Patterns on Continuous Cropping Tomato Growth，Yield and Soil Microflora and Enzymes Activities in Solar Greenhouse[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):46.
[9]杨会芳,梁新安,常介田,等.叶面喷施硒肥对不同蔬菜硒富集及产量的影响[J].北方园艺,2014,38(11):158.
YANG Hui-fang,LIANG Xin-an,CHANG Jie-tian,et al.Effects of Foliar Spraying of Selenium Fertilizer on Selenium Enrichment of Different Vegetables and Yield[J].Northern Horticulture,2014,38(15):158.
[10]祁连弟,管建慧,其日格,等.不同比例牛羊粪便栽培基质对温室番茄苗期生长的影响[J].北方园艺,2013,37(22):47.
QI Lian-di,GUAN Jian-hui,QI Ri-ge,et al.Effects of Different Nursery Substrates with Cow and Sheep Dung on the Seedlings Growth of Tomato in Solar Greenhouse[J].Northern Horticulture,2013,37(15):47.
备注/Memo
第一作者简介：高子星（1995-），男，硕士研究生，研究方向为设施作物栽培及生理生态。E-mail：gzx18309258403@126.com.责任作者：胡晓辉（1977-），女，博士，教授，博士生导师，现主要从事设施农业理论与生产技术等研究工作。E-mail:hxh1977@163.com.基金项目：杨凌示范区农业科技示范推广能力提升资助项目（TS-2016-15）;陕西省重点研发计划资助项目（2018TSCXL-NY-05-01）。收稿日期：2019-03-05